Are Smartwatches the Ideal Stepping Stone Before Smartphones for Children?

A Comprehensive Review of Smartwatches for Kids: Bark, Xplora, and Beyond

A child’s first watch is a milestone, but like most childhood accessoriestechnology now plays a part. 

As more parents weigh the decision of when to introduce their children to digital devices, smartwatches are increasingly viewed as a perfect middle ground between maintaining communication and protecting kids from the risks of the online world. With tech brands launching kid-friendly smartwatches, including Bark’s new model and Xplora’s popular range, parents now have several options to choose from.

This article explores the top smartwatches for kids on the market, diving into what each brand offers, from communication safety to fitness tracking. But are smartwatches really the best solution for your child?

Let’s find out.


1. Bark Smartwatch

Overview:

Bark, widely recognised for its AI-powered parental control software, has taken its expertise into the smartwatch space with its new Bark Watch. Known for monitoring social media and protecting kids from online risks, Bark brings many of these features to its smartwatch, focusing on safety, control, and real-time alerts.

Key Features:

  • Call and Text Monitoring: Bark’s watch allows children to text and call, but all communication is monitored, and parents can be alerted to potential risks, such as concerning language or unauthorised contacts.
  • GPS Tracking: Parents can view their child’s real-time location and set up geo-fenced safe zones. They receive alerts if the child leaves these zones.
  • AI-Powered Alerts: Bark’s standout feature is its AI alerts, notifying parents of potential issues related to communication or online safety.
  • Durability and Kid-Friendly Design: The watch is designed to be durable enough to withstand active kids and is available in bright, child-friendly colours.

Pros:

  • Advanced safety features powered by Bark’s AI.
  • Strong monitoring tools, ideal for cautious parents.
  • Real-time location tracking.

Cons:

  • May feel too controlling for older kids.
  • Limited customisation compared to other watches.

2. Xplora Smartwatches

Overview:

Xplora is one of the pioneers in the kids’ smartwatch space, with several models designed for both fun and safety. Their watches emphasise healthy activity alongside safe communication.

Key Features:

  • GPS and SOS Alerts: Like Bark, Xplora watches offer real-time GPS tracking and SOS buttons for emergencies. If a child needs help, they can instantly alert a parent.
  • Step Tracking and Activity Goals: Xplora watches gamify exercise by offering daily activity goals and step tracking. Some models even offer rewards for hitting activity milestones.
  • Limited Communication: Parents control who their child can call and text, with communication limited to approved contacts.
  • Camera and Fun Features: Many Xplora models come with cameras and fun, child-friendly features, adding an element of play without introducing excessive distractions.

Pros:

  • Promotes physical activity with built-in step tracking and fitness goals.
  • Safe, limited communication for peace of mind.
  • Kid-friendly design and fun features like cameras.

Cons:

  • Some models may lack advanced parental controls like Bark’s monitoring features.
  • Younger children may find activity features less engaging.

3. Garmin Bounce

Overview:

Garmin, known for its premium fitness trackers, has introduced the Garmin Bounce, a kid-specific smartwatch focusing on activity tracking and basic communication. With GPS, location tracking, and safety features, it’s a great option for active children.

Key Features:

  • Fitness Tracking: Garmin Bounce emphasises fitness with step counting, active minutes, and sleep tracking. Kids can set goals and challenge themselves.
  • GPS and Real-Time Tracking: Parents can track their child’s location and receive arrival/departure alerts from predefined zones.
  • Two-Way Messaging: Children can send texts and voice messages to pre-approved contacts, helping them stay in touch without the need for a phone.
  • Durable Design: Garmin smartwatches are known for their ruggedness, making them perfect for outdoor and active kids.

Pros:

  • Ideal for fitness-conscious families who want to promote a healthy lifestyle.
  • Excellent build quality, perfect for active children.
  • GPS tracking for real-time location monitoring.

Cons:

  • Lacks advanced safety features like Bark’s AI alerts.
  • More expensive than other smartwatches on the market.

4. TickTalk 4

Overview:

TickTalk is another contender in the kids’ smartwatch market, offering a device packed with features that combine safety, communication, and entertainment.

Key Features:

  • Video Calling: Unlike many other kids’ smartwatches, TickTalk 4 includes video calling, offering both voice and video communication with pre-approved contacts.
  • Messaging and Calling: Kids can send texts, photos, emojis, and voice messages, with full parental control over contacts.
  • GPS Location Tracking: Parents can monitor their child’s location in real-time and set geo-fenced safe zones.
  • Activity Tracking: The watch also includes step tracking and fitness goals to keep children active.

Pros:

  • Advanced communication options with video calls and voice messaging.
  • Easy-to-use GPS tracking with safety zones.
  • Fun and interactive features like emojis and step challenges.

Cons:

  • Slightly bulky design, not as sleek as other options.
  • Communication features may be overwhelming for very young children.

5. Angel Watch Series R

Overview:

The Angel Watch Series R is designed specifically for safety-conscious parents who want a smartwatch that goes beyond the basics of communication and fitness. With medical alerts, health monitoring, and emergency features, it’s a unique option for families who want comprehensive protection.

Key Features:

  • Heart Rate and Blood Pressure Monitoring: Unlike most smartwatches for kids, Angel Watch includes health monitoring for metrics like heart rate and blood pressure, making it ideal for children with health concerns.
  • GPS Tracking and Safe Zones: The watch offers GPS tracking and allows parents to set safe zones. Parents get alerts when the child leaves these zones.
  • Two-Way Calls and Messaging: The watch includes calling and messaging with approved contacts, much like other kid-friendly models.

Pros:

  • Comprehensive health monitoring features, including heart rate and blood pressure tracking.
  • Ideal for children with medical conditions.
  • Real-time GPS tracking and emergency SOS alerts.

Cons:

  • Health features may not be necessary for all kids.
  • More expensive than other models, reflecting its advanced features.

Final Thoughts: Which Smartwatch is Right for Your Child?

When choosing a smartwatch for your child, it’s essential to consider your priorities. If safety and monitoring are at the top of your list, Bark’s new smartwatch offers unrivaled features powered by AI. If you want a blend of safety and fun, Xplora or TickTalk are excellent choices. For fitness enthusiasts, the Garmin Bounce is perfect for promoting an active lifestyle, while the Angel Watch Series R is ideal for parents who prioritise health monitoring.

Ultimately, smartwatches are an excellent stepping stone before giving kids a smartphone. They teach digital responsibility, promote healthy habits, and offer a level of connectivity that gives kids some independence without overwhelming them. The right smartwatch can bridge the gap, offering both safety and learning opportunities as your child grows into the digital world.

Which smartwatch do you think suits your child’s needs?

Let me know your thoughts in the comments or reach out for advice on navigating the digital landscape with your family.

Which device is right for your child?

All of these gadgets offer pros and cons. Choosing one that makes sense for your family depends on how much connection your child needs and whether you want additional features, such as GPS tracking and parental controls.

Here are some questions I’ve written to ponder and to ask yourself before deciding on a smartwatch

Read more here on Wirecutter

Read more in The Independent